A joint Fermilab/SLAC publication

Researchers propose machine for a clean, mean neutrino beam


Scientists hope to enlist the help of muons in their quest to find a fourth type of neutrino.

Photo of NuMI horn

About 60 physicists met at Fermilab this past weekend to discuss an idea that might define the future of neutrino research. The scientists are interested in creating clean, precise beams of neutrinos by sending muons—the more massive cousins of electrons—to the racetrack.

Neutrinos are surprising little particles. They have mass, despite predictions to the contrary. They come in at least three types, called flavors, and they shift from flavor to flavor as they move.

Several experiments have hinted that another neutrino surprise may be in store: the existence of a fourth type of neutrino, a sterile neutrino. To search for it, scientists need to create the world’s cleanest, most precise neutrino beam, which they hope to do with a proposed project called nuSTORM.

“The technology to do this probably existed in some form 30 years ago,” says Fermilab physicist Alan Bross, who is leading the nuSTORM effort. “But it wouldn’t have been as powerful as we can make it today. Now a desire and an ability to make neutrino beams with higher precision and intensity have evolved.”

Scientists currently create beams of neutrinos by crashing protons into a target. Some of the particles that come out of these collisions are pions, which have an electric charge. Researchers use magnets (such as the NuMI focusing horn, pictured above) to steer these particles into one line until they decay into neutral neutrinos, which can no longer be controlled with magnetic forces and continue moving in a straight line.

The idea now on the table is to make a beam of neutrinos coming from decays of a different type of particle: the muon.

With nuSTORM (proposed layout on the map below), scientists would create beams of neutrinos by steering muons around a racetrack-shaped ring with long, straight sides (labeled "Muon Decay Ring" below). The majority of the neutrinos coming from muon decays would be catapulted in a straight line in one direction or the other.

Illustration of nuSTORM map

The beams would be more precise, and they’d also be cleaner because a beam of muons with the same charge would create specific pairings of neutrinos and antineutrinos. Positively charged muons decay into electron neutrinos and muon antineutrinos. Negatively charged muons decay into muon neutrinos and electron antineutrinos. Any neutrinos or antineutrinos of an unexpected flavor showing up in the neutrino beam would have to have come from a neutrino oscillation.

This is important because evidence for the existence of a fourth type would come from neutrinos oscillating faster than expected, at short distances from their sources.

“It’s called ‘the golden channel,’” Bross says. “It’s very, very powerful because the backgrounds are so small.”

Beyond the science motivation, the proposed experiment would also function as the first steps toward developing a larger neutrino factory or a muon collider, both ideas scientists have proposed as future projects at Fermilab.

According to a rough first estimate, the project would cost about $130 million, with more than 40 percent of the price coming from the large magnets needed to steer heavy muons.

This month, physicists at the European Strategy Meeting in Krakow said they were impressed with nuSTORM. In June, the Fermilab Physics Advisory Committee and Fermilab Director Pier Oddone also responded favorably to the idea.

Members of nuSTORM plan to present a full proposal for the project in June 2013.

Latest news articles
APS News

The P5 panel is gathering information that will shape its recommendations.

Drexel News

Volunteers from anywhere can participate in the “Name that Neutrino” project, which asks users to help categorize IceCube data. 


A new experiment pulled off the most precise measurement of an electron’s self-generated magnetic field—and the universe’s subatomic model is at stake.

Science Friday

Experts Janna Levin and Feryal Özel join Science Friday to talk about a theory linking dark energy to black holes, along with other recent black hole breakthroughs.