A joint Fermilab/SLAC publication
Image: Breaking: Chinese collider expands charm family
BESIII Collaboration

Chinese collider expands particle zoo


China’s Beijing Electron-Positron Collider seems to be hosting a reunion; members of a poorly understood family of particles keep popping up in their data, which may help clarify the properties of this reclusive family.

While much of the world’s attention remains transfixed on the Large Hadron Collider and its discovery of the Higgs boson, a continent away, another, smaller particle accelerator is churning out particles—including at least two brand-new and completely unexpected ones.

At China’s Beijing Electron-Positron Collider, a 350-member collaboration is looking at a group of particles called XYZ states. These particles “are something different and not yet understood—and therefore very interesting,” says University of Hawaii Professor Fred Harris, who has served as co-leader of the collaboration. Not only are the particles not predicted by the accepted theoretical models, but they also don’t decay as expected.

Since Fall 2012, the Beijing Electron Spectrometer collaboration has discovered at least two new charged particles, whose decays contain a charm quark, an anti-charm quark and additional conventional quarks that give the particle its charge.

Further analyses and more data will reveal insight into these particles, clarifying what they’re made of and how they relate to previously discovered particles.

“We’re not just adding more and more particles,” says Ryan Mitchell, an associate scientist at Indiana University who spent the past year in Beijing working on the BES-III experiment. “In fact, it’s the opposite. The picture is starting to get a little simpler; we’re starting to see patterns.”

Just the right energy

The collaboration started by colliding electrons and positrons at just the right energy to produce a particle called Y(4260). Other experiments, including BaBar at SLAC in the United States and Belle at KEK in Japan, had seen this particle previously but were unable to discern much about it because their accelerators were tuned to other energies and because Y(4260) particles were produced only indirectly via relatively rare processes. All that added up to just not seeing enough Y(4260) particles to be able to understand them well.

By tuning their experiment to exactly 4260 million electronvolts, the BES collaboration produces far more Y(4260) particles. And when they began analyzing their data, BES researchers were surprised to see other, new particles also produced in the collisions.

“The assumption is that we’re producing the Y(4260) and it’s decaying some of the time into these new states,” Harris says. “But it’s possible that something else is going on. We could be skipping the Y(4260) altogether and producing the new particles directly.”

The collaboration now seeks to reveal not only exactly how the new particles are being produced but also exactly what those new particles are.

Z and X

The first new particle to be discovered is called the Z_c(3900). This particle is unusual because, while it’s been known for quite some time that quarks form other particles by binding together in groups of twos or threes, this particle seems to be composed of four quarks. Since its discovery at the Beijing Electron-Positron Collider earlier this year, the Z_c(3900) has been confirmed by the Belle collaboration and through analysis of data from the CLEO experiment at Cornell University. That makes it the first confirmed Z particle.

More recently, the collaboration discovered other particles, which, like the Z_c(3900), appear to be made of four quarks. Together, these new particles seem to be part of a larger family of four-quark particles.

Overall, the collaboration has seen four unexpected decays: the original Z_c(3900), the Z_c(3885), the Z_c(4020), and the Z_c(4025). However, the properties of two of these decays are somewhat similar to the other two, so it’s possible that what the collaboration is seeing is really four different decays of just two new particles.

The collaboration has also observed a third particle, the X(3872), which was first experimentally observed over a decade ago. Although scientists have long suspected that this particle made up of four quarks, it has been difficult for them to definitively determine its components. The BES collaboration hopes that observations of the X(3872) alongside the Z_c(4020) and Z_c(3900) will soon lead to a more conclusive theoretical interpretation.  

“BES-III is starting to form connections between all of these X, Y and Z particles,” Mitchell says. “Before BES, we just had these particles that were very confusing. What we’re doing is to relate all of these particles and simplify the picture a little bit.”

In its next run, the collaboration will increase the energy at which the electrons and positrons collide. That should help reveal what exactly these particles are made of and what they have in common.

“The nature of the Y(4260) and Z_c particles can be investigated with more available data at BESIII, which may shed light onto a full understanding of the XYZ particles discovered in recent years,” says Shen Xiaoyan, spokesperson for the BES-III experiment and scientist at the Institute of High Energy Physics in Beijing.


Like what you see? Sign up for a free subscription to symmetry!
Latest news articles

Brookhaven Lab is celebrating 70 years since its founding and a century since the founding of the former US Army base where it operates.

Science News

Patience is a virtue in the hunt for dark matter. 

Inside Science

Burying certain instruments helps astronomers and astrophysicists detect otherwise difficult-to-spot particles.


Neural networks meet space

Artificial intelligence analyzes gravitational lenses 10 million times faster.