The LHC on "60 Minutes"

September 30, 2008 | 7:58 pm

You don’t see particle physics on current affairs television programs every night of the week. This weekend, “60 Minutes” had a story on the Large Hadron Collider.

The story could easily have ended up focused on the “controversy” of black hole creation at the LHC, but the “60 Minutes” team seem to have mostly kept to the facts and done their best to give a flavor of the project, the science, the culture, the people, and the applications. There are some great vignettes of a few US particle physicists talking about their involvement in the LHC, including Monica Dunford, who has a commentary in the new issue of symmetry.

You can watch the four segments of the show at cnet.com.

David Harris

No Comments »

A European strategy for astroparticle physics

September 29, 2008 | 12:54 pm

Today, ASPERA, the AStroParticle European Research Area, a network of European national funding agencies responsible for astroparticle physics, released a roadmap for the next decade. The report recommends priority instruments in seven sub-fields of astroparticle physics including direct dark matter searches with one-ton-scale detectors, double beta decay experiments to explore neutrino masses, a ground-based very-high-energy gamma-ray telescope array, and the underground gravitational wave detector dubbed the “Einstein Telescope.”

The report is based on an assumption of growth to doubled funding in the next eight years, a far more aggressive funding profile than has been assumed by US funding bodies in recent documents such as the recent P5 report.

ASPERA represents the following funding agencies in Europe: FNRS (Belgium), FWO (Belgium), MEYS (Czech Republic), CEA (France), CNRS (France), BMBF (Germany), PTDESY (Germany), DEMOKRITOS (Greece), INFN  (Italy), FOM (Netherlands), FCT (Portugal), IFIN-HH (Romania), FECYT (Spain), MEC (Spain), SNF (Switzerland), VR (Sweden), STFC (United Kingdom), and the European organization CERN.

Read more at the press release and roadmap PDF.

David Harris

No Comments »

LHC lawsuit dismissed

September 29, 2008 | 6:49 am

Those of you following closely already heard this news but, last Friday, a federal judge in Hawaii threw out a lawsuit alleging the Large Hadron Collider contravenes the National Environmental Protection Act, or NEPA. The lawsuit, brought by Walter Sanchez and Luis Sancho, was thrown out because the judge said the US involvement in the LHC was not sufficient for US environmental regulations to come into effect.

The judge did not evaluate the massive amount of documentation submitted by the parties arguing the scientific aspects of the case. That argument might need to be considered in the European Court of Human Rights where a companion lawsuit is under consideration.

Read more about the case and this decision in Alan Boyle’s extensive and excellent coverage of the topic at Cosmic Log.

David Harris

No Comments »

Does "Halo" make you think science or shootout?

September 26, 2008 | 4:33 pm

OK. I agree the name Large Hadron Collider lacks sex appeal or the ability to turn into a catchy acronym, but boring may be preferable to linking the world’s largest science experiment to violence and the military. 

In a poll organized by the Royal Society of Chemistry in London and reported in the Telegraphpeople voted to rename the LHC as Halo. According to the RSC, “Halo conjures visions of radiant beauty, power and wisdom. The circle of light reflects the collider’s form; it is a crowning achievement of science and engineering. It also gives more than a nod to the experiment’s importance to religious debate.”

Maybe in Europe. But in the United States, at least, Halo conjures up images of adolescents and short-attention-span adults wasting hours playing a first-person shooter video game while linked to other gamers across the globe via the Internet and a headset.

Death and destruction, even if just in a virtual world, doesn’t seem like something one would want associated with non-military basic research, period, especially in light of the black-hole-devouring-the-world lawsuits.

You can get an idea of how the game works by viewing these trailers.

Tona Kunz

2 Comments »

Greatest hits from LHC rap artist

September 25, 2008 | 8:16 am

Can’t get enough of AlpineKat and her LHC rap?

Well, learn more about her in this CNET.com article and listen to her two previous raps about Michigan State’s National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory and neurochips.

Tona Kunz

1 Comment »

LHC re-start scheduled for 2009

September 23, 2008 | 5:31 pm

CERN press release September 23, 2008

Investigations at CERN following a large helium leak into sector 3-4 of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) tunnel have indicated that the most likely cause of the incident was a faulty electrical connection between two of the accelerator’s magnets. Before a full understanding of the incident can be established, however, the sector has to be brought to room temperature and the magnets involved opened up for inspection. This will take three to four weeks. Full details of this investigation will be made available once it is complete.

“Coming immediately after the very successful start of LHC operation on 10 September, this is undoubtedly a psychological blow,” said CERN Director General Robert Aymar. “Nevertheless, the success of the LHC’s first operation with beam is testimony to years of painstaking preparation and the skill of the teams involved in building and running CERN’s accelerator complex. I have no doubt that we will overcome this setback with the same degree of rigour and application.”

The time necessary for the investigation and repairs precludes a restart before CERN’s obligatory winter maintenance period, bringing the date for restart of the accelerator complex to early spring 2009. LHC beams will then follow.

Particle accelerators such as the LHC are unique machines, built at the cutting edge of technology. Each is its own prototype, and teething troubles at the start-up phase are therefore always possible.

“The LHC is a very complex instrument, huge in scale and pushing technological limits in many areas,” said Peter Limon, who was responsible for commissioning the world’s first large-scale superconducting accelerator, the Tevatron at Fermilab in the USA. “Events occur from time to time that temporarily stop operations, for shorter or longer periods, especially during the early phases.”

CERN has received similar words of support from several laboratories, including Germany’s DESY, home of the HERA superconducting particle accelerator, which ran from 1992 to 2007.

“We at DESY have been following the commissioning of the LHC with great excitement and have been very impressed with the success of the first day,” said Albrecht Wagner, DESY Director. “I am confident that our colleagues at CERN will solve the problem speedily and we will continue to support them as much as we can.”

See original press release

Guest author

1 Comment »

Most dark-matter-filled galaxy discovered

September 22, 2008 | 12:05 pm

According to a press release from Yale University, a team led by one of their astronomers has found “the least luminous, most dark matter-filled galaxy known to exist.”

The dwarf galaxy, called Segue 1, gives off only a faint glow lit by a few hundred stars as it orbits the Milky Way.

“But despite its small number of visible stars, Segue 1 is nearly a thousand times more massive than it appears, meaning most of its mass must come from dark matter.”

According to the press release:

“It’s only recently that astronomers have discovered just how prevalent these dwarf satellite galaxies are, thanks to projects like the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, which imaged large areas of the nighttime sky in greater detail than ever before. In the past two years alone, the number of known dwarf galaxies orbiting the Milky Way has doubled from the dozen or so brightest that were discovered during the first half of the twentieth century.”

Fermilab processes and hosts data for the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. (Read more about SDSS in this symmetry article.)

The team will publish their results in an upcoming issue of The Astrophysical Journal (ApJ).

Kathryn Grim

No Comments »

LHC glitch means two month delay

September 20, 2008 | 10:22 am

On Friday, Sept. 19, at midday CERN time, one sector of the Large Hadron Collider warmed abnove superconducting temperature leading to the release of helium gas into the tunnel. The incident is likely due to a faulty electrical connection between two magnets, according to a CERN statement.

To repair the connection, the sector of magnets will need to be heated to room temperature. The heating, repair, and recooling process will take about two months to complete. CERN still hopes to have first collisions before the scheduled winter shutdown, which happens each year due to the much higher energy prices in the Geneva winter.

Last week, a power transformer on the surface failed, but was quickly replaced allowing the affected sector to be cooled again. These kinds of hiccoughs in starting up a large collider are not surprising as the LHC has millions of critical components. Every major accelerator and collider in past decades has faced these kinds of teething problems during the startup phase and scientists and engineers are confident that all issues with the LHC will be resolved satisfactorily.

Update: Read more about the incident at the New York Times, BBC News, and the London Times. And more from the BBC.

David Harris

1 Comment »

Discuss dark matters at the Smithsonian

September 19, 2008 | 7:06 am

Source: Robert Kirschner; NASA/WMAP Science Team

Scientists know a lot about the 4 percent of the universe that makes up visible matter such as planets and people.

But the other 96 percent remains a mystery.

What makes up that combination of undiscovered matter and cosmic energy, dubbed dark matter and dark energy, poses one of the greatest questions in modern science.

And physicists have ideas about where to find the answer. Astrophysicist Rocky Kolb, of the University of Chicago, and Fermilab particle physics theorist Joe Lykken will explain at a lecture next week in Washington, DC, how particle accelerators, satellites, telescopes, and underground detectors are preparing to shine light on dark matter and dark energy.

Photos courtesy of Fermilab

Unraveling that mystery could open the door to a radical, new understanding of our universe.

“Dark matter and dark energy are the two most important topics in all of science,” says cosmologist Michael Turner, who will moderate the lecture. Last year at the Smithsonian, Turner moderated a sold-out, lively debate about String Theory, one of the most controversial concepts in particle physics.

Turner, of the University of Chicago, is known for drawing speakers out of their comfort zones with provocative questions.

“He’s a master at it,” says Melody Curtis, senior program coordinator for the Smithsonian Associates. “He brings out the best in people.”

The lecture will be held at 7 p.m. on Wednesday, Sept. 24, at Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History. General admission is $20.

Scientists first found evidence of dark matter in 1935. They theorized that clumps of dark matter formed the backdrop to individual galaxies, holding them together as planets and stars formed.

About a decade ago, scientists discovered that an opposite force was pushing the universe apart, expanding its boundaries at an increasing rate. This could be caused by dark energy, Turner says.

“Dark matter and dark energy are the two dark titans that have controlled the evolution of the universe,” he says.

Like dark energy, dark matter has eluded direct detection so far. Other than that, the two don’t seem to have much in common.

“Dark matter is unevenly distributed out there in the universe,” Lykken says. “There’s hunks of it here, and there’s hunks of it over there.

“Dark energy, on the other hand–if it exists at all–is evenly spread out through the whole universe. So there’s just as much dark energy in this office as there is in a same-sized cube out in intergalactic space.”

Dark energy’s gravity does not attract. Instead, it repels, like boys and girls at a middle school dance. So it’s spreading itself farther and farther out.

That does not mean our galaxy will pull apart anytime soon, Turner says. “In our own galaxy, the dark energy is overwhelmed by the dark matter that’s here.” But understanding dark energy could give us a view of the future of the universe.

Source: SLAC and Nicolle Rager

Today, using different research tools in the three frontiers of particle physics, scientists are working together to answer questions about dark matter and dark energy.

To discover how the universe formed, scientists use particle accelerators, such as the Large Hadron Collider near Geneva, Switzerland, to replicate energies and temperatures that existed just after the big bang. Because the LHC will create energies seven times greater than any particle accelerator before it, scientists hope to produce and record particles that disappeared an instant after the big bang, including the theorized dark matter particle.

Other tools scientists hope will give them a better understanding of the origin of the universe will help them search for dark matter particles floating through the Earth and the effects of dark matter and dark energy in outer space.

Scientists have improved an experiment called the Cryogenic Dark Matter Search by adding to a collection of underground detectors they hope will identify dark matter as it passes through the Earth.

The Department of Energy and NASA are at work on plans for a Joint Dark Energy Mission, which proposes to send a telescope into space to determine whether the expansion of the universe is accelerating and if dark energy is the cause.

“This is an extraordinary time,” Turner says. “There are discoveries just over the horizon. And if history is an example, we’ll probably be surprised.”

What it All Means

Photo courtesy of the Smithsonian

It’s also possible that these types of experiments–the particle accelerator, the underground dark matter detectors, and the satellite telescope–could prove theories about dark matter and dark energy wrong.

“What that would mean is that we’ve actually broken through to a new level,” Lykken says. “That would be great.”

Basic scientific research often prompts unforeseen developments.

“When people played around with batteries and magnets,” Lykken says, “it didn’t seem like it was really good for anything. It turned out it was.”

The idea that a rotating magnet could generate power now governs power plants across the world.

“It was that connection between magnetism and electricity that first revolutionized our society,” Lykken says. “It’s the reason we’re not all freezing in the dark.”

Another idea that only seemed useful for intellectual stimulation was quantum mechanics, formulated in the 1920s to explain the strange behavior of particles inside atoms.

“Only a dozen people in the world understood it,” Lykken says. “About 30 years later, John Bardeen invented the transistor based on quantum mechanics.” And that has served as the basis for electronics since.

The tools of research can also find new uses in different fields, such as medicine. Particle physics research has contributed to Computer-Aided Tomography (CAT scans), Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), Positron Emission Tomography (PET scans), and cancer treatment.

Turner says he cannot predict how new understanding of dark matter and dark energy will be used but said he trusts in the power of basic research.

“In the long run, it changes not only the way we look at the universe,” he says, “but it also changes the way we live–and for the better.”

Kathryn Grim

No Comments »

Particle physics vs. Britney Spears

September 18, 2008 | 6:08 am

In today’s online information age, the measure of a topic’s popularity has become how many “hits,” or views, an item can receive online and how many bloggers or niche online publications willingly pick up the story.

Well then, high-energy physics is very trendy.

The Canberra Times, an Australian newspaper, called particle physics “sexy,” pointing out the plethora of media coverage in the four days before the Sept. 10 launch of the first beam to circulate the 17-mile Large Hadron Collider ring at CERN, the European high-energy particle physics laboratory.

“A rap video clip, showing dancing scientists in white lab coats and hard hats rappin’ the LHC on location in those high-tech tunnels, had had more than 2.5 million hits on You Tube in the last four days.”

Winning over the hearts, and arguably limited attention spans, of a public that supports numerous movie and music gossip magazines, reality television shows, and homemade YouTube video clips, is no small task, as the article highlighted.

“Yesterday’s revelation that troubled British singer Amy Winehouse is buying a country farmhouse ‘to escape her demons’ generated 47 news stories. Britney Spears did slightly better with around 60 stories on her MTV music awards makeover and plans for a Christmas album. But on Google News yesterday, there were just under 4000 news reports on the Large Hadron Collider’s warm-up experiments, and the mix of elation and doomsday hysteria the switch-on had generated.”

Read the full article.

Tona Kunz

No Comments »